Yes, I take the deductions for mortgage interest and property taxes. Just the same, I think we all can live without either of them, and probably should — in time.
Most important, they're not fair. Renters pay their landlords' mortgage interest and property taxes, but the landlords get the tax advantages. Those who can afford the biggest, most expensive homes get the greatest benefit, and those who can afford multiple homes get even more. Change has to happen — but given the popularity of of the mortgage and property tax deductions, the big question is how to get those particular loopholes closed.
As Lord Robert Baden-Powell, homosexual hero of the Siege of Mafeking in the Boer War and founder of the Boy Scouts is reputed to have said, "Softly, softly, catchee monkey." (Damn, those Brit colonialists were so attuned to those they conquered and oppressed. Nevertheless...)
"Softly, softly" means not all at once. That makes a lot of sense. People (with encouragement from their realtors) factor in tax savings when they buy. Realtors are able to convince them they can afford houses far larger and fancier than they really ought to be considering. Granted, if they lost their mortgage interest deductions all at once, there would be a hell of a lot more foreclosures.
The obvious answer is to cap the mortgage interest deduction — so only mortgagees of relatively expensive
houses would be screwed. After that, we could drop the cap, year by year. After
ten or fifteen years, the deduction would be gone. Housing prices would fall,
gradually, and families would stop buying more house than they really
could afford. Since mortgage interest is front-loaded, current homeowners should feel little financial impact year to year. New buyers should be able to predict how the phase-out of the deduction would impact them, and let that help guide their home buying decisions.
The property tax deduction could be phased out in much the same way, only faster. The greatest impact would be in wealthier, higher-tax areas — and the change might create political pressure for the states to take on more of the burden of funding education, which might create greater equity among school districts.
By the way, I believe the phase-out of any and all deductions should be accompanied by higher tax rates, because when government takes money out of people's pockets, it has an obligation to put some back by providing better services and benefits — but for all, not just for some.
Thursday, December 6, 2012
Tuesday, December 4, 2012
Charitable deductions
Now that there's serious talk of capping deductions from both sides of the aisle, all sorts of interest groups are up in arms trying to carve out exceptions. I'm not privy to which K Street firms are collecting the largest fees from whom, but I hear an awful lot of noise about the impact on charities.
Donations to organizations that are ideological in nature are not tax deductible — except when they are. I am not allowed to deduct my contributions to the ACLU, for example, because defending First Amendment rights is, presumably, "political." Okay, I can live with that. We ACLU members cannot deduct our contributions, but guess what? We keep on giving.
One third of all deductible contributions in the United States go to religious organizations. I imagine some portion of those contributions goes towards feeding the hungry and clothing the naked and such like. I know that a substantial part goes to proselytizing and missionary work, and I can't see how converting a sucker from one set of cockamamie beliefs to another is any sort of public good. Tax deductible contributions also are used for agitating on political issues like abortion, contraception, gay marriage, suppression of competing religious practices, etc.
Will members stop donating to their religious organizations if their contributions no longer are tax deductible? I doubt it — not if they want that afterlife they've been promised.
Then there are the religiously and ethnically affiliated "social welfare" organizations, many of which operate commercial enterprises like bars, bowling alleys, and catering halls. Paying your tax deductable dues to those gets you cut-rate booze, a convenient place for your Thursday night poker game, and a less expensive venue for your daughter's wedding. Similar non-sectarian groups provide many of the same benefits, but serve primarily to provide ocassions where local businessmen can hobnob and arrange business transactions. Yes, such groups do involve themselves in charitable work, but nobody joins for the tax advantage.
People who donate to medical charities usually are motivated by having known someone who suffered with the illness to which the charity is dedicated, not by a tax deduction. Also, I'm pretty sure rich people will continue to pay to see their names featured on bronze plaques in the lobby of the ballet or outside the hospital emergency room, not to mention engraved on the lintels of university buildings.
Frankly, I don't think capping (or even eliminating) the deduction for charitable contributions would have much impact at all — but if charities having a little less to spend means I'll stop getting all those useless address labels, it's okay with me.
Donations to organizations that are ideological in nature are not tax deductible — except when they are. I am not allowed to deduct my contributions to the ACLU, for example, because defending First Amendment rights is, presumably, "political." Okay, I can live with that. We ACLU members cannot deduct our contributions, but guess what? We keep on giving.
One third of all deductible contributions in the United States go to religious organizations. I imagine some portion of those contributions goes towards feeding the hungry and clothing the naked and such like. I know that a substantial part goes to proselytizing and missionary work, and I can't see how converting a sucker from one set of cockamamie beliefs to another is any sort of public good. Tax deductible contributions also are used for agitating on political issues like abortion, contraception, gay marriage, suppression of competing religious practices, etc.
Will members stop donating to their religious organizations if their contributions no longer are tax deductible? I doubt it — not if they want that afterlife they've been promised.
Then there are the religiously and ethnically affiliated "social welfare" organizations, many of which operate commercial enterprises like bars, bowling alleys, and catering halls. Paying your tax deductable dues to those gets you cut-rate booze, a convenient place for your Thursday night poker game, and a less expensive venue for your daughter's wedding. Similar non-sectarian groups provide many of the same benefits, but serve primarily to provide ocassions where local businessmen can hobnob and arrange business transactions. Yes, such groups do involve themselves in charitable work, but nobody joins for the tax advantage.
People who donate to medical charities usually are motivated by having known someone who suffered with the illness to which the charity is dedicated, not by a tax deduction. Also, I'm pretty sure rich people will continue to pay to see their names featured on bronze plaques in the lobby of the ballet or outside the hospital emergency room, not to mention engraved on the lintels of university buildings.
Frankly, I don't think capping (or even eliminating) the deduction for charitable contributions would have much impact at all — but if charities having a little less to spend means I'll stop getting all those useless address labels, it's okay with me.
Monday, November 26, 2012
Morsi and the media
Mohammed Morsi is in a difficult situation right now, but no more so than the American media. Okay, it is tempting just to go along with Mohammed el Baradei, traditional "friend of the West," and accuse Morsi of aspiring to be a new "Pharaoh," but it's a lot more complicated. What we have to remember is that the Egyptian revolution against Mubarak is far from complete, and the American media still is trying to figure out which side "we're" on.
Yes, Morsi's assumption of pretty much autocratic powers is kind of out of synch with American values, but I think we still must take into account that the real struggle in Egypt is between Morsi and the Mubarak judiciary, still hanging on with firmly clenched teeth as a surrogate for the Egyptian Army. That judiciary, in case you forgot, was the power center that dissolved the popularly elected parliament and the first assembly charged with re-writing Egypt's Constitution. In recent days, it has been moving towards dissolving the current constitutional assembly as well. That judiciary wants nothing better than an opportunity to put the army back in charge of everything.
Oh, pathetic American media, forced to choose! You can slant your coverage towards the Mubarak judiciary, which would be easier because it's not "Islamist," or you can slant your coverage towards Morsi because, at least, he was popularly elected — and the favoritism shown by the courts to the Mubarak thugs was hard to miss.
In the long run, though, Egypt will have to work things out for itself.
Yes, Morsi's assumption of pretty much autocratic powers is kind of out of synch with American values, but I think we still must take into account that the real struggle in Egypt is between Morsi and the Mubarak judiciary, still hanging on with firmly clenched teeth as a surrogate for the Egyptian Army. That judiciary, in case you forgot, was the power center that dissolved the popularly elected parliament and the first assembly charged with re-writing Egypt's Constitution. In recent days, it has been moving towards dissolving the current constitutional assembly as well. That judiciary wants nothing better than an opportunity to put the army back in charge of everything.
Oh, pathetic American media, forced to choose! You can slant your coverage towards the Mubarak judiciary, which would be easier because it's not "Islamist," or you can slant your coverage towards Morsi because, at least, he was popularly elected — and the favoritism shown by the courts to the Mubarak thugs was hard to miss.
In the long run, though, Egypt will have to work things out for itself.
Labels:
Constitution,
Egypt,
el Baradei,
Morsi
Tuesday, November 20, 2012
Short subjects for November
Allen West, America's favorite Tea Party Negro, finally admitted he lost his bid for a second term in the House. On the other hand, he has not yet admitted to being a moron, despite his loss to newcomer Patrick Murphy after outspending the former Republican by four to one. Does Murphy count as a Democratic gain in the House? Well, he's not nearly as liberal as Nixon, but then neither is Obama.
Israel is losing the media war, having killed a shitload of Gazan children while losing none of its own. Killing children never is good PR — something to which Our President should pay attention as his drone strikes kill children in Pakistan, Afghanistan, Yemen, and wherever else the CIA has been transformed into a paramilitary organization. Just because drone strikes don't put American soldiers in peril doesn't mean they don't put America in peril. After every strike, more people hate our guts.
The fiscal cliff, it seems, is not a cliff — it is more of a bluff. Wall Street, apparently, has received word that nothing it will mind too much is likely to happen. Walmart and some other megacompanies have moved up their dividend payments to late December instead of early January, so it looks like taxes on dividends really will go up. All the stock sales that depressed the market earlier last week might mean the capital gains rate might go back up to 20%, but I wouldn't bet on it.
Timmy Geithner soon will be leaving Treasury, and far less than a few moments too soon — but who will replace him? If Obama nominates Erskine Bowles, Obama will be further down my shit list than ever before. How about Sheila Bair? Hell, she's a Republican, and a hell of a lot more reasonable and intelligent than most of the Obama coterie. Let's validate responsible Republicans.
Thanksgiving always has been my favorite holiday. I'm looking forward to mine. May yours be joyous.
Israel is losing the media war, having killed a shitload of Gazan children while losing none of its own. Killing children never is good PR — something to which Our President should pay attention as his drone strikes kill children in Pakistan, Afghanistan, Yemen, and wherever else the CIA has been transformed into a paramilitary organization. Just because drone strikes don't put American soldiers in peril doesn't mean they don't put America in peril. After every strike, more people hate our guts.
The fiscal cliff, it seems, is not a cliff — it is more of a bluff. Wall Street, apparently, has received word that nothing it will mind too much is likely to happen. Walmart and some other megacompanies have moved up their dividend payments to late December instead of early January, so it looks like taxes on dividends really will go up. All the stock sales that depressed the market earlier last week might mean the capital gains rate might go back up to 20%, but I wouldn't bet on it.
Timmy Geithner soon will be leaving Treasury, and far less than a few moments too soon — but who will replace him? If Obama nominates Erskine Bowles, Obama will be further down my shit list than ever before. How about Sheila Bair? Hell, she's a Republican, and a hell of a lot more reasonable and intelligent than most of the Obama coterie. Let's validate responsible Republicans.
Thanksgiving always has been my favorite holiday. I'm looking forward to mine. May yours be joyous.
Labels:
allen west,
fiscal cliff,
Geithner,
Hamas,
Israel
Wednesday, November 14, 2012
The Petraeus Fiasco
Hey! Remember when MoveOn.org drew so much flak for calling General Petreaus "General Betray-us?" Well, guess what? They got that one right.
I rapidly departed MoveOn when they moved from Kucinich (our favorite) to Obama without even consulting the so-called membership. I was of the opinion that either Edwards or Clinton would have been a better choice, and I still think I was right. Nevertheless, MoveOn was dead right about Petraeus.
Personally, I don't care who he was screwing, then or now — albeit, I understand that Obama felt obliged to offer his tender virgin hole to the Great General by approving the"surge" because he thought that he had to; and Obama gave Petraeus the CIA post last year because it was the only way to get him out of the Army, where he worked against the president (approximately) 96.7% of the time, and kept us in Afghanistan years longer than made any sense.
I'm very glad the scrawny but "fit" little shit is getting what he deserves, and I hope his chubby wife, despite her lack of "toned" arms and fetching(?) armpits, gets his entire military pension when she divorces him. Also, I hope that the multinational that hires him goes broke. (Yes, I'm a little vindictive, but we're talking about thousands of dead American soldiers here.)
Anyway, Maureen Dowd got it totally right today in her Times column, the first analysis of the "scandal" that makes any sense at all. Read it.
I rapidly departed MoveOn when they moved from Kucinich (our favorite) to Obama without even consulting the so-called membership. I was of the opinion that either Edwards or Clinton would have been a better choice, and I still think I was right. Nevertheless, MoveOn was dead right about Petraeus.
Personally, I don't care who he was screwing, then or now — albeit, I understand that Obama felt obliged to offer his tender virgin hole to the Great General by approving the"surge" because he thought that he had to; and Obama gave Petraeus the CIA post last year because it was the only way to get him out of the Army, where he worked against the president (approximately) 96.7% of the time, and kept us in Afghanistan years longer than made any sense.
I'm very glad the scrawny but "fit" little shit is getting what he deserves, and I hope his chubby wife, despite her lack of "toned" arms and fetching(?) armpits, gets his entire military pension when she divorces him. Also, I hope that the multinational that hires him goes broke. (Yes, I'm a little vindictive, but we're talking about thousands of dead American soldiers here.)
Anyway, Maureen Dowd got it totally right today in her Times column, the first analysis of the "scandal" that makes any sense at all. Read it.
Labels:
afghanistan,
Petreaus,
scandal,
sex scandals,
surge
Tuesday, November 13, 2012
Totally nutzzz
I was just watching the news about the craziness surrounding the Petraeus debacle, and it keeps getting more and more crazy. I cannot pretend to understand what in hell is going on, except for the undenyable fact that men who exercise power have a hard time keeping their dicks in their pants. Is that why Mitt Romney lost? Not enough testosterone?
Anyway, this morning's Times confirmed that I'm not the only one thinking that Mitt Romney's idea for a cap on deductions and credits, as mentioned in my previous post, is not such a bad idea. Needless to say, the cap being considered is more than twice what I (and Romney, at least once) had in mind — $35,000.
So who's against it? Well, according to the Times, universities and other major recipients of charitable contributions. Needless to say, they want exemptions, and they'll probably get them — and that makes the whole idea useless. The biggest beneficiaries, I'd guess, would be religious organizations — the Catholics, the Baptists, the Mormons, the Jews, the Muslims, the Scientologists, and all the other well intentioned scam artists currently enjoying tax favoritism — oh! and let's not forget 501(c)(3) organizations like Crossroads GPS.
Anyway, I guess we'll all just be distracted for a while by the escapades of generals and their lady friends. Obama met with union and progressive leaders today. Are they happy? I doubt it. Tomorrow he meets with corporate big shots. Will they be happy?
I sure as hell hope not.
Anyway, this morning's Times confirmed that I'm not the only one thinking that Mitt Romney's idea for a cap on deductions and credits, as mentioned in my previous post, is not such a bad idea. Needless to say, the cap being considered is more than twice what I (and Romney, at least once) had in mind — $35,000.
So who's against it? Well, according to the Times, universities and other major recipients of charitable contributions. Needless to say, they want exemptions, and they'll probably get them — and that makes the whole idea useless. The biggest beneficiaries, I'd guess, would be religious organizations — the Catholics, the Baptists, the Mormons, the Jews, the Muslims, the Scientologists, and all the other well intentioned scam artists currently enjoying tax favoritism — oh! and let's not forget 501(c)(3) organizations like Crossroads GPS.
Anyway, I guess we'll all just be distracted for a while by the escapades of generals and their lady friends. Obama met with union and progressive leaders today. Are they happy? I doubt it. Tomorrow he meets with corporate big shots. Will they be happy?
I sure as hell hope not.
Labels:
fiscal cliff,
Petreaus,
tax deductions
The View from the Fiscal Cliff
Yes, the "fiscal cliff" is a metaphor, but metaphors, to one extent or another, represent somebody's impression of reality. The somebodies in question, this time around, are the Fed and the Congressional Budget Office, so their metaphor deserves a hard look. The CBO estimates that "going over the cliff" will result in close to a 2 per cent drop in GDP — and hence a pretty substantial drop back into recession, sending unemployment back up to 9 per cent, and putting most of the long term unemployed kind of permanently out-of-luck.
Boehner is scared. Obama is scared. Sadly, a great many of those assholes elected to the House by undereducated rednecks are not scared at all, so it behooves us to take a look over the cliff and see what might be at the bottom.
Three factors come together at the end of the year: the end of the "Bush" tax cuts, the end of the Obama payroll tax cuts, and the dreaded "sequestration," which would cut large chunks out of the military budget and the non-"entitlement" civilian budget. Let's have a look.
The payroll tax cuts are pure stimulus, intended to promote consumer spending, and generally expected to lapse this time around. They are most beneficial to the working class, which is good enough reason to expect they will be the first tax cuts to go. (Nobody seems to be talking about eliminating the cap on FICA, which would make Social Security viable for at least another generation, and probably forever.)
Sequestration takes a cleaver to places where scissors and scalpels are more appropriate, although both military and non-military budgets could stand a good look. Anyway, it won't happen. The whole idea of sequestration was to make things too uncomfortable for both Democrats and Republicans to let it happen. They won't.
On to the Bush tax cuts: current talk involves increasing revenues rather than rates. The Democrats still are making noises about raising taxes on the rich, which seems to be perfectly acceptable to the majority of Americans, who are not rich. Personally, I like Romney's idea of putting a limit on deductions and credits, and I think his $17,000 suggestion might be in the right neighborhood.
Too big a MacMansion? Tough. If you live in a smaller house, you can deduct all the mortgage interest. Too many kids? Tough. Try a little birth control — and, if contraception violates your religious beliefs, there's always abstinence. Granted, limited charitable deductions may be a little tough on certain ballet companies and museums, but it wouldn't inhibit my regular contributions to Doctors Without Borders (deductible), ACLU (non-deductible), public TV and radio (deductible), or the Committee in Solidarity with the People of El Salvador (definitely not deductible.)
It is starting to sound like Obama might resist wimping out this time around — which is to say, he might be willing to let all the Bush tax cuts expire if the Tea Party assholes push him against the wall. Let's hope his balls have re-descended now that he doesn't have to worry about re-election.
(Let's also hope that Timmy Geithner's replacement never met Robert Rubin.)
Boehner is scared. Obama is scared. Sadly, a great many of those assholes elected to the House by undereducated rednecks are not scared at all, so it behooves us to take a look over the cliff and see what might be at the bottom.
Three factors come together at the end of the year: the end of the "Bush" tax cuts, the end of the Obama payroll tax cuts, and the dreaded "sequestration," which would cut large chunks out of the military budget and the non-"entitlement" civilian budget. Let's have a look.
The payroll tax cuts are pure stimulus, intended to promote consumer spending, and generally expected to lapse this time around. They are most beneficial to the working class, which is good enough reason to expect they will be the first tax cuts to go. (Nobody seems to be talking about eliminating the cap on FICA, which would make Social Security viable for at least another generation, and probably forever.)
Sequestration takes a cleaver to places where scissors and scalpels are more appropriate, although both military and non-military budgets could stand a good look. Anyway, it won't happen. The whole idea of sequestration was to make things too uncomfortable for both Democrats and Republicans to let it happen. They won't.
On to the Bush tax cuts: current talk involves increasing revenues rather than rates. The Democrats still are making noises about raising taxes on the rich, which seems to be perfectly acceptable to the majority of Americans, who are not rich. Personally, I like Romney's idea of putting a limit on deductions and credits, and I think his $17,000 suggestion might be in the right neighborhood.
Too big a MacMansion? Tough. If you live in a smaller house, you can deduct all the mortgage interest. Too many kids? Tough. Try a little birth control — and, if contraception violates your religious beliefs, there's always abstinence. Granted, limited charitable deductions may be a little tough on certain ballet companies and museums, but it wouldn't inhibit my regular contributions to Doctors Without Borders (deductible), ACLU (non-deductible), public TV and radio (deductible), or the Committee in Solidarity with the People of El Salvador (definitely not deductible.)
It is starting to sound like Obama might resist wimping out this time around — which is to say, he might be willing to let all the Bush tax cuts expire if the Tea Party assholes push him against the wall. Let's hope his balls have re-descended now that he doesn't have to worry about re-election.
(Let's also hope that Timmy Geithner's replacement never met Robert Rubin.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)