As the economists keep telling us, the market isn't the economy. True, I suppose, but if you're a retiree living on a 401K or a 403B, it sure as hell is your economy.
Some are blaming recent market losses on China. Some are blaming low oil prices. Some are blaming the Fed's .25% increase in the Federal Funds Rate last month. (It wasn't the Fed. There's no way a quarter per cent above, essentially, zero, could have such an impact.)
Others are pointing to "volatility," suggesting that January's big dip in prices is just a temporary glitch. We'll see. On the other hand, there are things that can be done to reduce "volatility" and its impact in the future.
One surefire policy choice would be passing a Tobin Tax, sometimes called a "Robin Hood tax" — a very small tax on every financial transaction. It would probably put the brakes on a lot of the high-frequency trading that exacerbates volatility. Bernie says the proceeds would be enough to finance free college tuition for all.*
The other change would be policies to encourage a return to fixed-benefit pension systems, so retirees don't have to ride the market roller coaster. Professional money managers would be in charge of their pension funds, just as they are with 401K funds, but pensioners would be freed of the stresses of market swings. Needless to say, this would require that pension funds be fully funded, and not subject to raids by municipal and state governments nor corporate fat cats.
Any money manager who is a consistent winner in the markets either is preternaturally lucky or engaged in insider trading, so with proper regulation, fund incomes should average out over time. Requiring contributions to an insurance fund that could bail out funds that are managed by the preternaturally unlucky would provide a safety net.
I know it all sounds highly unlikely, but most of it is feasible if the political will can be found.
*Those who claim we can't have free tuition because we don't want to subsidize rich people are talking out of their asses. The rich will continue to send their kids to top-ranked private schools. Donald Tr*mp's son will not be attending CUNY!
Showing posts with label college tuition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label college tuition. Show all posts
Thursday, January 28, 2016
Sunday, May 27, 2012
Romney on Education
I just read the Romney campaign's "white paper" on education. Absolutely nothing in it surprised me.
Central to Mitt's K-12 "reform" are vouchers. He praises George W. Bush's DC Opportunity Scholarship Program, which Barack Obama allowed to lapse. It provided federal funds to allow poor DC children to attend "private" schools. Needless to say, the only "private" schools poor families could afford, given the size of the scholarships, were religious schools — resulting in direct federal subsidies of religious education.
While the Romney model includes a lot of talk of poor children leaving poorly performing schools, reading slightly between the lines we imply that his idea is that every child should be able to take his or her share of public spending on education to the school of his or her parents' choice. In some states, which offer "scholarship" programs for children to attend private schools at taxpayer expense, children are learning that Earth is 6000 years old, and that the fossil record reflects the aftermath of Noah's flood. (I can't be entirely sure, but it looks like those stay-at-home moms "home schooling" their kids might also be able to suckle at the public teat. It's certain, though, that those entrepreneurial types offering online "schooling" would qualify.)
Romney would provide block grants to states that eliminate teacher tenure and seniority rules. He wants to remove teacher certification requirements, which might impede "talented" individuals from entering the field. Needless to say, he is just as enamored of testing children to evaluate their teachers and schools as all the other clowns tumbling out of their clown cars into the political arena. Of course the questions might be a little different.
Finally, Romney calls for (you guessed it) deregulation of colleges. The main thrust of that would be eliminating the Obama regulation that for-profit schools provide prospective students with data on what proportion of their graduates find gainful employment, in the field for which they trained, upon graduation. Clearly, such regulation stifles entrepreneurs like those who created the "Draw Me" Matchbook School of Art and Late-Night Cable HVAC University.
Granted, I think Obama's basketball buddy Arne Duncan is a perfectly awful Secretary of Education. On the other hand, things could get worse — much, much worse.
Central to Mitt's K-12 "reform" are vouchers. He praises George W. Bush's DC Opportunity Scholarship Program, which Barack Obama allowed to lapse. It provided federal funds to allow poor DC children to attend "private" schools. Needless to say, the only "private" schools poor families could afford, given the size of the scholarships, were religious schools — resulting in direct federal subsidies of religious education.
While the Romney model includes a lot of talk of poor children leaving poorly performing schools, reading slightly between the lines we imply that his idea is that every child should be able to take his or her share of public spending on education to the school of his or her parents' choice. In some states, which offer "scholarship" programs for children to attend private schools at taxpayer expense, children are learning that Earth is 6000 years old, and that the fossil record reflects the aftermath of Noah's flood. (I can't be entirely sure, but it looks like those stay-at-home moms "home schooling" their kids might also be able to suckle at the public teat. It's certain, though, that those entrepreneurial types offering online "schooling" would qualify.)
Romney would provide block grants to states that eliminate teacher tenure and seniority rules. He wants to remove teacher certification requirements, which might impede "talented" individuals from entering the field. Needless to say, he is just as enamored of testing children to evaluate their teachers and schools as all the other clowns tumbling out of their clown cars into the political arena. Of course the questions might be a little different.
Which of these is the approximate age of the Earth?As far as higher education is concerned, Romney's main concern is to re-privatize the college loan program. Things were much better, after all, when the banks serviced loans made with federal money — with no bank funds at risk — and collecting all the fees and interest. Romney's Wall Street buds clearly regretted losing that cash cow.
a. 4.5 billion years
b. a million years, give or take a million
c. 6000 years
d. a little older than grandma
Finally, Romney calls for (you guessed it) deregulation of colleges. The main thrust of that would be eliminating the Obama regulation that for-profit schools provide prospective students with data on what proportion of their graduates find gainful employment, in the field for which they trained, upon graduation. Clearly, such regulation stifles entrepreneurs like those who created the "Draw Me" Matchbook School of Art and Late-Night Cable HVAC University.
Granted, I think Obama's basketball buddy Arne Duncan is a perfectly awful Secretary of Education. On the other hand, things could get worse — much, much worse.
Labels:
college debt,
college tuition,
education,
Mitt Romney,
vouchers
Monday, December 5, 2011
Occupy CUNY
I'll start with a complaint. Why am I making contributions to an alumni association that did not inform me of the November 21st "Occupy CUNY" march on Wall Street? I'd have been there, and so would a lot of other long-ago graduates who went to CUNY... those of us who went for FREE.
We geezers who attended the schools of the City University of New York before 1976 paid no tuition. Why, I have to wonder, was New York City able to do it then, but not now?
Well, the city has lost a hell of a lot of state aid over the years — but where did that money go? I'm still not sure. Also, I'm not sure where the federal money went, specifically, except that the later seventies were the time that tax rates on the rich began their precipitous fall.
College should be free. It's hard enough to make it out of the working class — and if you have to put yourself in ridiculously crazy debt you can't even shed in bankruptcy court to get a little bit beyond where your parents were, it may never happen. (Are there any corporate debts that can't be shed in bankruptcy? I can't think of any.)
Back in the sixties, I'm sure I could have qualified for some financial aid, and probably won a scholarship or two, but I doubt it would have been enough to get me all the way through a private college. It's certainly not enough for many students today, especially since jobs for those without college degrees are in such short supply and pay so poorly (and since full-time work and full-time school really are incompatible.)
The Occupy movement is about economic inequality — but also points out how generally screwed up our priorities have been for the past few decades. It's really time to get them straightened out.
We geezers who attended the schools of the City University of New York before 1976 paid no tuition. Why, I have to wonder, was New York City able to do it then, but not now?
Well, the city has lost a hell of a lot of state aid over the years — but where did that money go? I'm still not sure. Also, I'm not sure where the federal money went, specifically, except that the later seventies were the time that tax rates on the rich began their precipitous fall.
College should be free. It's hard enough to make it out of the working class — and if you have to put yourself in ridiculously crazy debt you can't even shed in bankruptcy court to get a little bit beyond where your parents were, it may never happen. (Are there any corporate debts that can't be shed in bankruptcy? I can't think of any.)
Back in the sixties, I'm sure I could have qualified for some financial aid, and probably won a scholarship or two, but I doubt it would have been enough to get me all the way through a private college. It's certainly not enough for many students today, especially since jobs for those without college degrees are in such short supply and pay so poorly (and since full-time work and full-time school really are incompatible.)
The Occupy movement is about economic inequality — but also points out how generally screwed up our priorities have been for the past few decades. It's really time to get them straightened out.
Labels:
college,
college debt,
college tuition,
occupy Wall Street
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)