Showing posts with label nuclear agreement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nuclear agreement. Show all posts
Saturday, May 12, 2018
Bully Diplomacy
I hate bullies; but even more, I despise those who succumb to bullying. Now that bullying is America's official, default foreign policy, I only can hope that its intended victims have the courage to resist.
Iran, of course, has no choice but to resist: it is not about to "negotiate" regime change, and nothing less than that will satisfy the Tr*mp gang (which includes Bibi and MbS.) The courage will have to come from Europe, and how much courage European leaders can muster remains to be seen.
Despite the easing of sanctions under Obama, US investment in Iran was minimal following the nuclear agreement: US companies continued to be limited by other sanctions protocols, and benefits to the Iranian economy fell far short of what Rouhani and his moderates hoped to see. Europeans were less restrained, so the impact of US withdrawal from the deal depends on European willingness to go along. It still remains to be seen what secondary sanctions the Tr*mpistas decide to impost on European companies that remain in Iran.
While secondary sanctions against US "allies" would be economically damaging, Macron and Merkel might be willing to endure them for the political advantage that might entail. Anti-Americanism is a tried and true means of garnering nationalist support, so a "principled" stand against the Tr*mpians well might draw away supporters of the National Front in France and the AfD in Germany. Suing the US at the WTO would be a good start, but withdrawing their ambassadors to the US in protest would be a sure bet for solidifying voters behind them.
If any diplomatic intelligence remains in the Tr*mp administration, secondary sanctions against the Europeans will be minimal, and the denuclearization of Iran can continue. If the yahoos prevail, though, we only can hope Europe finds the courage to resist.
Labels:
Iran,
Macron,
Merkel,
nuclear agreement,
sanctions
Wednesday, July 15, 2015
The Iran Deal
As long-term readers know, I couldn't care less if Iran becomes a nuclear power. There are lots of nuclear powers in the world today, and none of them has used its bomb. Even though it's well over half a century old, mutually assured destruction (MAD) still works. India and Pakistan may rattle their silos from time to time, but they never launch. Even if Israel didn't have enough nuclear weapons to vaporize all their antagonists in the region, Iran still would not risk using a nuke. Hell, even Israel won't use its nuclear weapons unilaterally.
So, what's the benefit of a nuclear treaty with Iran? More than anything, it brings the Iranians closer to the rest of the world. By comparison with their neighbors, Iranians are better educated, less religiously fanatical, and much better disposed towards democracy. After all, it was the democratic election of Hassan Rouhani that made the nuclear agreement possible.
Reintegrating Iran into the world economy will make it more responsive to external influence. Alleviating the hardships suffered by average Iranians under sanctions will lessen the influence of the Revolutionary Guard and other right-wing elements. Further sanctions will not work (see Cuba), and the only other alternative is war, which also will not work (see Iraq.)
The time to normalize relations with Iran is now.
So, what's the benefit of a nuclear treaty with Iran? More than anything, it brings the Iranians closer to the rest of the world. By comparison with their neighbors, Iranians are better educated, less religiously fanatical, and much better disposed towards democracy. After all, it was the democratic election of Hassan Rouhani that made the nuclear agreement possible.
Reintegrating Iran into the world economy will make it more responsive to external influence. Alleviating the hardships suffered by average Iranians under sanctions will lessen the influence of the Revolutionary Guard and other right-wing elements. Further sanctions will not work (see Cuba), and the only other alternative is war, which also will not work (see Iraq.)
The time to normalize relations with Iran is now.
Friday, April 10, 2015
How to Sabotage a Nuclear Agreement
An unsubstantiated rumor believed to have started on this blog, today, would have it that Paul Wolfowitz, neoliberal co-architect of the US invasion of Iraq, is currently on loan from the Jeb Bush presidential campaign to Mohammed bin Salman, de facto ruler of Saudi Arabia (see post of April 4, below.) If true, a Wolfowitz influence would go a long way towards explaining why Saudi Arabia has invaded Yemen to restore the "democratically elected" Hadi administration to power.
First, a word on that "democratic" election. Abd Rabbuh Mansur Hadi ran unopposed, in an election boycotted both by the Houthis and Yemen's southern secessionists. His previous experience was as vice-president to the "democratically elected" Ali Abdullah Saleh, who was forced to resign by the Gulf Cooperation Council, which consists of Saudi Arabia and the other Sunni oil monarchies of the Persian Gulf. Saleh and his loyalists now are allied with the Houthis.
In what looks most like a barefaced attempt to sabotage the agreement between Iran and its six negotiating partners announced last week, the USofA announced it would be supporting the Saudi invasion of Yemen. (Note: Saudi Arabia is the number one armaments importer in the world, buys most of its weapons from the United States, certainly would not need any extra help if bin Salman were competent, and is unlikely to profit from whatever help is forthcoming.)
Why did Obama take exactly the wrong step at exactly the wrong time? Did he intend to sabotage the proposed agreement by backing the Saudis and letting Kerry strongly suggest that the Houthis are Iranian puppets? Was the intent to back out of the nuclear arms agreement while forcing Iran to take the blame? Did he go out of his way to provoke the Grand Ayatollah?
That's how it looks to me — and I have no difficulty imagining Bibi Netanyahu, John Boehner, and all Congressional sucklers at the AIPAC teat (of both parties) sitting back with smug smiles on their faces. Maybe there's something more subtle going on, but if so, it's too subtle for me. What next?
First, a word on that "democratic" election. Abd Rabbuh Mansur Hadi ran unopposed, in an election boycotted both by the Houthis and Yemen's southern secessionists. His previous experience was as vice-president to the "democratically elected" Ali Abdullah Saleh, who was forced to resign by the Gulf Cooperation Council, which consists of Saudi Arabia and the other Sunni oil monarchies of the Persian Gulf. Saleh and his loyalists now are allied with the Houthis.
In what looks most like a barefaced attempt to sabotage the agreement between Iran and its six negotiating partners announced last week, the USofA announced it would be supporting the Saudi invasion of Yemen. (Note: Saudi Arabia is the number one armaments importer in the world, buys most of its weapons from the United States, certainly would not need any extra help if bin Salman were competent, and is unlikely to profit from whatever help is forthcoming.)
Why did Obama take exactly the wrong step at exactly the wrong time? Did he intend to sabotage the proposed agreement by backing the Saudis and letting Kerry strongly suggest that the Houthis are Iranian puppets? Was the intent to back out of the nuclear arms agreement while forcing Iran to take the blame? Did he go out of his way to provoke the Grand Ayatollah?
That's how it looks to me — and I have no difficulty imagining Bibi Netanyahu, John Boehner, and all Congressional sucklers at the AIPAC teat (of both parties) sitting back with smug smiles on their faces. Maybe there's something more subtle going on, but if so, it's too subtle for me. What next?
Labels:
Ayatollah,
bin Salman,
Iran,
Kerry,
nuclear agreement,
Obama,
Saudi Arabia,
Yemen
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
